GTM Uncensored
← All editions

By Adam Jay · Nov 22, 2026 · 4 min read

Your Discount Log Is an ICP Diagnostic

GTM Uncensored

A discount log often contains more ICP evidence than the buyer persona deck, and I wish more leadership teams used the evidence.

Whenever I review pricing, I read the exception log before the pricing deck. The deck tells me what leadership wanted the market to do, while the log shows what buyers, reps, finance, and delivery taught the company to do after the deck met reality... which is usually where the useful story starts.

Most pricing committees do the opposite, reviewing one request, debating one percentage, approving or rejecting the concession, and moving on as if the next request arrived from another planet. Nothing says strategy quite like approving the same exception over and over, then continuing to call every one a special case.

The exception is usually the evidence

I treat each request as a clue because the same approval email might point to weak value proof, the wrong package, a crowded segment, a procurement habit, or a customer whose implementation burden exceeds the contract. Those problems look similar when the only field anyone reads is discount percentage, even though each one leads to a different decision.

A practical review starts with the last 20 opportunities where price changed or stopped the deal. For each one, capture the segment, use case, buyer role, the first moment price became an objection, what the buyer wanted removed or added, the concession approved, final margin, delivery burden, and where the opportunity ended.

Once those records sit next to one another, the pattern tends to get less mysterious. If resistance disappears after the buyer sees a quantified problem, your proof needs work. If one segment keeps asking for the same feature bundle and rejects the rest, the package needs work. If procurement asks for a familiar concession after the business buyer has committed, the approval rules need work. If low-fit customers demand heavy implementation and lower pricing, your target market needs work.

The percentage alone tells me almost nothing. High discounting paired with strong renewal, low delivery effort, and fast expansion supports a deliberate commercial trade, while the same discount paired with long onboarding, heavy support, and weak renewal points to a segment whose economics never worked, so the same percentage leads to a completely different leadership decision.

Change price after the pattern is clear

I also won't let sales and finance run this review alone, because delivery usually remembers every promise made after the objection appeared. Sales remembers the conversation, finance remembers the margin, and delivery is still paying for the concession three months later through onboarding work, support time, and scope nobody priced correctly.

For an operating partner, the portfolio question becomes uncomfortable in a useful way: where are repeated commercial exceptions changing the business model without an explicit investment decision?

Leadership wants one clean answer because one answer produces one clean action, except the evidence rarely cooperates. One pattern calls for coaching, another calls for tighter ICP boundaries, another calls for better proof, and another calls for a package or approval change.

I won't support a market-wide price cut because a few loud deals made the approval channel uncomfortable. Show me the pattern and where the economics break, then choose whether to narrow the ICP, rebuild the proof, change the package, or tighten the approval gate. Until then, lowering price is a guess... and an expensive lesson to teach the entire market.

If this field note would help another operator, forward the note and subscribe here.

ON THE AIR

Fiona Covington joins Adam Jay and Dale Zwizinski on GTM Uncensored

The Playbook Your Best Rep Is Hiding From You

Fiona Covington, founder of ReflectPath, joins Adam and Dale to explain how sales teams mine losses, ignore wins, and let the methods behind their best reps walk out the door. The conversation covers competency evidence, deal analysis, and the human work required after AI finds the pattern.

START WITH THE DIAGNOSIS
Most GTM problems get treated before anyone proves what is broken. The GTM Growth Plan™ uses your data to name the real gap, show whether what you think you need is what you actually need, and give you the options for what to do next.

Adam and Dale

Prefer to listen?Get the same operators, unscripted, on the GTM Uncensored podcast.→

Get the next edition

Join 5,200+ revenue leaders. Unfiltered GTM strategy & knowledge, every Sunday.